
Legally reviewed by Eric Hageman, Managing Partner — Explosion + Burn Legal Team

When a pipeline explodes, multiple investigations start within hours. Most of them are not on the survivors’ side.
Who shows up at the scene
Within hours: the operator’s own field crews, the operator’s legal team, the local fire department, the state fire marshal, the regional Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) office, and in many cases the National Transportation Safety Board. The press arrives soon after. Insurance adjusters arrive too — sometimes wearing the same vests as utility crews. Survivors and families need to know that not all of these people are working in their interest.
What the operator’s investigators are looking for
The operator’s investigators are looking for one thing: a theory of cause that does not involve operator negligence. They will look for ground disturbance by third parties, damage by contractors, customer-side equipment failures, and any natural cause — wind, earthquake, lightning — that could shift the blame. Their investigation will be thorough, well-funded, and motivated.
What independent investigators look for
Our team’s investigators look for what the operator’s investigators are trying to overlook. We hire independent metallurgists to physically examine the ruptured pipe. We hire control-room reconstruction experts to walk through the SCADA data — what the operator’s monitoring saw, when, and what was done about it. We hire pipeline integrity experts to audit the operator’s integrity management program. See our full pipeline explosion lawsuit guide for the framework.
Why preservation letters matter
Within 24 hours of getting involved, we send preservation letters. These letters put the operator on legal notice that they cannot destroy, alter, or remove physical evidence, data, or records. Failure to preserve evidence after such notice invites severe court sanctions later. Without the preservation letter, the operator can claim — sometimes truthfully — that the records were destroyed in the normal course of business.
The PHMSA investigation
PHMSA is the federal regulator for pipelines. Its investigators are usually competent, but they are also resource-constrained. PHMSA’s investigation focuses on regulatory compliance and may take years. PHMSA findings can be useful in civil litigation but are not dispositive. Don’t wait for PHMSA to act — the civil case has its own clock.
Documents, documents, documents
Pipeline cases are won and lost in document discovery. The operator’s records — inspection logs, maintenance work orders, prior incident reports, complaint history, regulatory filings, board-level safety memos — contain the case. Skilled discovery counsel knows what to ask for and how to find it. Discovery battles are sometimes the most consequential phase of the litigation.
For the legal framework on this topic, see Pritzker Hageman’s main resource: https://www.pritzkerlaw.com/explosion-lawyer/. To talk to Eric Hageman or another member of our explosion + burn legal team about your situation, call 1-888-377-8900 or fill out our contact form.
